Re AH [2021] EWCA Civ 1768

Judicial visits This appeal against a Court of Protection serious medical treatment decision was allowed because of the nature of the judge's visit to the patient in hospital: it may have been that the judge considered AH to have given him some insight into her wishes; if so, the judge's decision was undermined because (a) it was strongly arguable that the judge was not equipped properly to gain any such insight (the validity of any such assessment might well have required further evidence or submissions) and (b) the parties needed to be informed about this and given an opportunity to make submissions. The Court of Appeal provided the following guidance pending any update to the guidance issued by Charles J: "Clearly, these matters will need to be determined before any visit takes place and after hearing submissions or observations from the parties: (a) Whether the judge will visit P; (b) The purpose of any visit; (c) When the visit is to take place and the structure of the visit (in other words, how the visit it to be managed; what is to happen during it; and whether it is to be recorded and/or a note taken); (d) What is to happen after the visit. This will include, depending on the purpose of the visit, how the parties are to be informed what occurred; when and how this is to happen; and how this will fit within the hearing so as to enable it to be addressed as part of the parties' respective cases."

Essex

This case has been summarised on page 23 of 39 Essex Chambers, 'Mental Capacity Report' (issue 118, December 2021).

Essex search

This case's neutral citation number appears in the following newsletters:

• 39 Essex Chambers, 'Mental Capacity Report' (issue 119, February 2022)

CASES DATABASE

Full judgment: BAILII

Subject(s):

• Other capacity cases🔍

Date: 25/11/21🔍

Court: Court of Appeal (Civil Division)🔍

Judge(s):

• McFarlane🔍
• Moylan🔍
• Nicholas Patten🔍

Parties:

• Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust🔍
• AH🔍
• A🔍
• M🔍
• S🔍
• K🔍

Citation number(s):

• [2021] EWCA Civ 1768^B
• (2022) 184 BMLR 1, [2022] 1 WLR 2437^B, [2022] 2 All ER 909, [2022] COPLR 253, [2022] WLR 2437

What links here:

• Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust v AH [2021] EWCOP 51
• 39 Essex Chambers, 'Mental Capacity Report' (issue 118, December 2021)
• Guidance: Judicial visits to 'P' [2022] EWCOP 5

Published: 31/12/21 08:06

Cached: 2024-10-11 15:43:47