Log in / create account
Website:
Google:
MAIN »
Main page
1. CASE LAW
2. LEGISLATION
3. GENERAL INFO
Help page and contact details
Site map
CPD »
CPD (12 points for £60)
BOOKS »
Bookshop
Eldergill
UPDATES »
Recent updates
Free email updates
Twitter @mhlonline
CASE LAW »
Index to mental health case law
Cases to be added
Settled cases and forthcoming judgments
LEGISLATION »
Index to legislation
MHA »
Overview of MHA 1983
Overview of MHA 2007
Full text of MHA 1983
Codes of Practice
Reference Guide
Regulations
Tribunal Rules
MCA »
Overview of MCA 2005
Full text of MCA 2005
Codes of Practice
Court of Protection
Office of the Public Guardian
Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards
FORMS »
MHA Statutory Forms
MHA Information Leaflets
Foreign-language MHA information leaflets
DOLS Standard Forms
Court of Protection forms
GENERAL »
Index to general information
Glossary
Legal Aid News
Consultations
Statistics
Events
No Javascript: See site map
Category:Northern Irish cases
From Mental Health Law Online
Jump to:
navigation
,
search
The pages below are initially ordered according to the dates on which they were added to the site (most recent first). The order can be changed by clicking on the symbol beside a column heading: click on the symbol beside "Page and summary" for alphabetical order; click beside "Categories" for the order in which the cases were reported. Click on the arrow symbol again to reverse the order. Click on a page name to view the relevant page.
Page and summary
Date added to site
Categories
Re JR49 (Application for Judicial Review) (2011) NIQB 41
—
The order authorising removal from a hospital in NI to a hospital in England pursuant to
MHA 1983 s82
was quashed.
2011-05-26
2011 cases
,
Brief summary
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Transcript
SSNI, Re Judicial Review (Oswald Brown) (2006) NIQB 94
—
It was lawful for the hunger-striking prisoner, who lacked capacity, to be given nutrition.
2010-01-12
2006 cases
,
Best interests
,
Brief summary
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Transcript
Re BS (2009) NIFam 5
—
A medical examination of BS in the context of an application for a Controller to be appointed in respect of her affairs would not breach
Article 8
and should take place.
2009-04-12
2009 cases
,
Brief summary
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Other capacity cases
,
Transcript
Magowan, Re Judicial Review (2009) NIQB 6
— Unsuccessful judicial review of failure of social services to make arrangements which would have allowed discharge from hospital.
2009-04-12
2009 cases
,
Community care
,
No summary
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Transcript
X, Re Judicial Review (2009) NIQB 2
—
Based on the general legislative purpose underlying Article 77(2) Mental Health (NI) Order 1986 and the constitutional principle in favour of liberty, the MHRT in Northern Ireland does not have the power to direct the discharge of an unrestricted patient at a future date where there is a mandatory duty to discharge the patient; a deferred discharge is only lawful for a discretionary discharge
2009-01-11
2009 cases
,
Brief summary
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Powers
,
Transcript
R v Warwick (2008) NICC 42
—
As the
Mental Health (Northern Ireland) Order 1986
does not allow detention for personality disorder, the risks in this case could only be addressed by the imposition of a discretionary life sentence (which would be followed by a transfer to Carstairs) rather than a hospital order.
2008-12-06
2008 cases
,
Brief summary
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Other criminal law cases
,
Transcript
McGrady, Re Application for Judicial Review (2003) NIQB 15
—
(1) The ability to disclose material to the representative on condition that it was not revealed to the patient was compatible with the Convention (obiter, since no decision had been taken on this yet). (2) The medical member's role is to form a provisional view on the patient's mental condition, rather than on the statutory criteria, and he discloses his conclusion during the hearing; if this approach is taken then there is no violation of
Article 5
(4),
DN v Switzerland 27154/95 (2001) ECHR 235
distinguished.
2008-11-27
2003 cases
,
Bias
,
Brief summary
,
Miscellaneous
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Transcript
McGee, Re Judicial Review (2007) NICA 38
—
The detention of the claimant under Article 7 of the Mental Health (NI) Order 1986 (similar to s5(2) MHA 1983) following a MHRT decision to discharge was lawful: (1) the authorities had formed the bona fide opinion that his mental state had since deteriorated; (2) Article 7 applied since the claimant had not divested himself of his in-patient status.
2008-02-22
2007 cases
,
Brief summary
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Re-sectioning after hearing
,
Transcript
R v Francis (2008) NICA 6
—
Both hospital orders to which the claimant was subject were quashed, on the basis that when sentenced he had not been suffering from severe mental impairment as defined in the Mental Health (Northern Ireland) Order 1986.
2008-02-22
2008 cases
,
Brief summary
,
Hospital order cases
,
Northern Irish cases
,
Transcript
Article titles
The following 9 pages are in this category.
M
Magowan, Re Judicial Review (2009) NIQB 6
McGee, Re Judicial Review (2007) NICA 38
McGrady, Re Application for Judicial Review (2003) NIQB 15
R
R v Francis (2008) NICA 6
R v Warwick (2008) NICC 42
Re BS (2009) NIFam 5
R cont.
Re JR49 (Application for Judicial Review) (2011) NIQB 41
S
SSNI, Re Judicial Review (Oswald Brown) (2006) NIQB 94
X
X, Re Judicial Review (2009) NIQB 2
This page belongs to the following categories
:
Case law - by jurisdiction
Northern Ireland
This page was last modified at 14:51 on 29 October 2009. Page credits:
Jonathan
Privacy policy
Copyrights
Disclaimers
Powered by MediaWiki
Gumax design