MHLO Annual Review 2013: Paperback | Kindle

Email updates | Email discussion list | Twitter

Fennell, Letts and Wilson, Mental Health Tribunals (Law Society 2013):
Foreword | Review | Amazon | Law Society bookshop | 20% discount

CPD scheme (12 points for £60)




Gray v Thames Trains Ltd (2007) EWHC 1558 (QB)

From Mental Health Law Online

Jump to: navigation, search

The principle of ex turpi causa prevented the claimant from recovering damages after the commission of manslaughter.

Related judgments

Gray v Thames Trains Ltd (2009) UKHL 33

  • Gray v Thames Trains Ltd (2007) EWHC 1558 (QB)

Brief summary

The claimant was a passenger in the Ladbroke Grove train crash who subsequently suffered from PTSD, committed manslaughter and was detained. He sought damages for negligence. The defendant admitted liability but argued that the principle of ex turpa causa prevented the claimant from recovering any damages from the date of the manslaughter conviction.

Held: in so far as the claimant's claim relates to losses suffered after the commission of the act of manslaughter, that claim must be dismissed.

External link

Bailii

Law Reports website - Permission to appeal to HL given 27/10/08