Sign up for MHLO on the Subscriptions page: you can sign up for free email updates, the email discussion list, the online forum and the CPD scheme (which provides 12 hours for £60 and is suitable for lawyers and non-lawyers).

Online forum | Latest topic on forum: Powers of Tribunal to discharge to lower security

DL-H v Partnerships in Care [2013] UKUT 500 (AAC), [2013] MHLO 93

This is the latest in a series of cases considering personality disorder, refusal to engage in treatment, and the question of whether the 'appropriate medical treatment is available' test in s72 is met. (1) Refusal to engage is not decisive but is potentially a relevant factor that has to be taken into consideration - although a patient may well continue to satisfy the conditions for detention despite refusing to engage. (2) In this case, the tribunal did not seem to have asked itself whether the deterioration after recall might not have been a response to detention rather than a manifestation of his mental disorder: this was relevant to the questions of 'nature/degree' and of whether the available treatment was appropriate, so the decision was set aside.

Related judgments

DL-H v Partnerships in Care [2013] UKUT 500 (AAC), [2013] MHLO 93

DL-H v Devon Partnership NHS Trust [2010] UKUT 102 (AAC)

External link

BAILII

Transcript on OSSCSC website