Category

2002 cases

Case and summary Date added Categories
Ms B v An NHS Hospital Trust [2002] EWHC 429 (Fam) — "The Claimant, whom I shall call Ms B, seeks declarations from the High Court in its exercise of the inherent jurisdiction. She claims that the invasive treatment which is currently being given by the respondent by way of artificial ventilation is an unlawful trespass. The respondent is the NHS Hospital Trust (the Trust) responsible for the hospital which is currently caring for Ms B, (the Hospital). At the request of the court the Official Solicitor instructed Mr Peter Jackson QC to act as Advocate to the Court. The main issue is whether Ms B has the capacity to make her own decision about her treatment in hospital. Underlying this important issue is the tragic story of an able and talented woman of 43 who has suffered a devastating illness which has caused her to become tetraplegic and whose expressed wish is not to be kept artificially alive by the use of a ventilator." [Paras 1 and 2 of judgment.] 2012‑01‑05 20:31:06 2002 cases, No summary, Other capacity cases, Transcript


Re S (Adult Patient) (Inherent Jurisdiction: Family Life); Sheffield City Council v S [2002] EWHC 2278 (Fam) — Dispute between a local authority and S‘s father, DS, as to where S should live: prior to the events which precipitated the proceedings, S had always lived at home with DS. [Summary required.] 2011‑12‑10 13:00:54 2002 cases, Best interests, Missing from Bailii, No summary, Transcript


R (Tagoe-Thompson) v The Hospital Managers of the Park Royal Centre [2002] EWHC 2803 (Admin)Panel of three hospital managers must be unanimous in order to discharge patient. 2011‑04‑10 10:23:50 2002 cases, Brief summary, Hospital managers hearings, Transcript


South West London and St George's Mental Health NHS Trust v W [2002] EWHC 1770 (Admin) — Lawfulness of transfer from prison to hospital (treatability). [Summary required.] 2009‑11‑01 21:25:11 2002 cases, No summary, Transcript, Treatability test and psychopathic disorder


R v Cornelius (Alan) [2002] EWCA Crim 138 — Extended period of licence reduced from 5 to 2 years on appeal. [Summary required.] 2009‑11‑01 21:18:06 2002 cases, No summary, Sentence appeal cases, Transcript


R v Czarnota (Michael) [2002] EWCA Crim 785 — Restriction order quashed on appeal. [Summary required.] 2009‑11‑01 21:15:04 2002 cases, No summary, Restriction order cases, Transcript


R (SSHD) v MHRT, re PG [2002] EWHC 2043 (Admin) — Inadequate reasons. [Summary required.] 2009‑11‑01 21:14:08 2002 cases, No summary, Reasons, Transcript


R (S) v SSHD and Parole Board [2002] EWHC 2424 (Admin) — Licence recall while on s3. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:46:40 2002 cases, No summary, Prison law cases, Transcript


R (S) v Airedale NHS Trust [2002] EWHC 1780 (Admin) — Seclusion. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:42:29 2002 cases, Miscellaneous, No summary, Transcript


R (N) v Dr M [2002] EWHC 1911 (Admin) — Unsuccessful challenge to compulsory treatment. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:40:09 2002 cases, Challenges to compulsory treatment, No summary, Transcript


R (Munjaz) v Ashworth Hospital Authority [2002] EWHC 1521 (Admin) — Departure from Code of Practice. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:37:54 2002 cases, Miscellaneous, No summary, Transcript


R (M) v Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust [2002] EWHC 1400 (Admin) — Unsuccessful challenge to s47/49 patient's return to prison. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:33:25 2002 cases, Ministry of Justice, No summary, Transcript


R (LH) v MHRT [2002] EWHC 170 (Admin) — Permission to appeal against Tribunal decision refused. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:27:56 2002 cases, No summary, Reasons, Transcript


R (L) v MHRT [2002] EWHC 618 (Admin) — AWOL claimant's delay case struck out as an abuse of process. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:22:41 2002 cases, No summary, Other Tribunal cases, Transcript


R (Heather) v Leonard Cheshire Foundation [2002] EWCA Civ 366 — Care home closure. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:18:00 2002 cases, Community care, No summary, Transcript


R (LH) v MHRT [2002] EWHC 1522 (Admin)(1) There is no need for reasons for not making a recommendation where, as here, there is no contention (or any evidence in support of a contention) justifying a recommendation or the consideration of it. (2) In any event, an extra-statutory recommendation, outside the scope of s72(3), has no legal effect and is not susceptible to judicial review. (3) That s72 does not allow consideration of a hospital's suitability in terms of security or family proximity does not disclose a Convention incompatibility: a lacuna in an Act or a failure to provide an effective remedy for a Convention violation does not mean that the Act is incompatible. 2009‑10‑31 18:14:55 2002 cases, Brief summary, Reasons, Transcript


R (D) v SSHD [2002] EWHC 2805 (Admin) — Parole Board and Mental Health Tribunal. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:05:52 2002 cases, No summary, Other Tribunal cases, Prison law cases, Transcript


R (DR) v Mersey Care NHS Trust [2002] EWHC 1810 (Admin) — Renewal of section while on long-term s17 leave. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 18:04:06 2002 cases, Miscellaneous, No summary, Transcript


R (C) v Brent, Kensington and Chelsea and Westminster Mental Health NHS Trust [2002] EWHC 181 (Admin) — Closure of residential accommodation. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑31 17:56:30 2002 cases, Community care, No summary, Transcript


R (B) v Ashworth Hospital Authority [2002] EWHC 1442 (Admin)A patient could be treated for any form of mental disorder, not just a disorder within the classification under which he was detained. 2009‑10‑30 23:16:02 2002 cases, Brief summary, Other classification cases, Transcript


Masterman-Lister v Brutton and Co [2002] EWCA Civ 1889 — Unsuccessful appeal against decision that M was fully capable of managing and administering his property and affairs. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑30 23:11:10 2002 cases, No summary, Other capacity cases, Transcript


Masterman-Lister v Jewell [2002] EWHC 417 (QB) — M was fully capable of managing and administering his property and affairs. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑30 23:08:45 2002 cases, No summary, Other capacity cases, Transcript


Dillon v SSHD [2002] EWHC 732 (Admin) — "This Claimant’s application is that a warrant, issued by the Secretary of State for the Home Department under section 3 of the Repatriation of Prisoners Act 1984 should be amended to substitute for the discretionary life sentence, with a tariff period of seven years, an order under section 37 of the Mental Health Act with a restriction order under section 41. Alternatively, to amend the warrant to remove the tariff period." [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑30 23:03:35 2002 cases, Life sentence cases, No summary, Transcript


Cook v Bradford Community Health NHS Trust [2002] EWCA Civ 1616 — Negligence case. [Summary required.] 2009‑10‑30 23:01:34 2002 cases, Miscellaneous, No summary, Transcript


Ashworth Hospital Authority v MGN Ltd [2002] UKHL 29 — MGN ordered to disclose identity of intermediary, as a means of identifying the source of the leaked information. 2009‑04‑12 23:40:52 2002 cases, Miscellaneous, No summary, Transcript


R (SSHD) v MHRT, re PH [2002] EWHC 1128 (Admin)Condition of discharge not to leave without escort not unlawful on the facts. 2009‑04‑12 13:01:39 2002 cases, Brief summary, Deprivation of liberty, Discharge conditions, Transcript


R (Stennett) v Manchester City Council [2002] UKHL 34S117 is not a gateway section; it contains no charging provision; therefore, no charge should be made for after-care under that section, including for caring residential accommodation. 2009‑04‑11 20:50:28 2002 cases, After-care, Brief summary, Transcript


R v Shepherd (Jack) [2002] EWCA Crim 1091 — Conviction quashed and substituted with an admission order with restrictions as, had the issue been raised, on the evidence the jury would have found that the defendant was unfit to plead but had done the act. 2009‑04‑11 14:48:25 2002 cases, No summary, Transcript, Unfitness and insanity cases


R v R [2002] EWCA Crim 165 — Appeal against restriction order allowed. 2009‑04‑11 14:45:14 2002 cases, No summary, Restriction order cases, Transcript


R v Kearney [2002] EWCA Crim 2772 — Appeal against restriction order allowed. 2009‑04‑11 14:41:16 2002 cases, No summary, Restriction order cases, Transcript


R v Johnson (Frank) [2002] EWCA Crim 1900 — Conviction quashed as during trial the defendant had become unfit to plead. 2009‑04‑11 14:39:43 2002 cases, No summary, Transcript, Unfitness and insanity cases


R v Gunning (Neville) [2002] EWCA Crim 634 — Three-year prison sentence quashed and substituted with hospital order. 2009‑04‑11 14:35:09 2002 cases, No summary, Sentence appeal cases, Transcript


R v Goode [2002] EWCA Crim 1698 — Appeal against restriction order refused. 2009‑04‑11 14:32:46 2002 cases, No summary, Restriction order cases, Transcript


Nowika v Poland 30218/96 [2002] ECHR 795The detention for 83 days of the applicant under Article 5(1)(b) (the lawful arrest or detention of a person for non-compliance with the lawful order of a court or in order to secure the fulfilment of any obligation prescribed by law) violated Article 5(1) as it was for longer than necessary for the fulfilment of the obligation to submit to a psychiatric examination; the restriction on visits by her family to one visit per month violated Article 8; compensation of €10,000 was awarded 2009‑04‑10 15:22:01 2002 cases, Brief summary, ECHR, ECHR deprivation of liberty cases, Transcript


Morley v UK 16084/03 [2002] ECHR 853The applicant had been transferred from hospital back to prison. He argued that his Article 5(4) right to review of his detention had been breached as the transfer had been ordered by the executive rather than a court, and asserted that he was still of unsound mind within Article 5(1)(e). This complaint was rejected (judicial review is sufficient) and his Article 8 complaint also failed. 2009‑04‑10 14:36:29 2002 cases, Brief summary, ECHR, Ministry of Justice, Transcript


Grey v UK 34377/02 [2002] ECHR 854A Tribunal granted an absolute discharge because the claimant suffered from no mental disorder, but on judicial review this was quashed because they had not first considered conditional discharge; a subsequent Tribunal reclassified him and upheld continued detention; his complaint under Article 5(1)(e) was rejected (no duty immediately and unconditionally to release into the community), as were complaints under Article 5(4) (no undue delay) and Article 6 (no right to appeal). 2009‑04‑10 13:24:35 2002 cases, Absolute or conditional discharge, Brief summary, ECHR, Transcript


A v A Health Authority [2002] EWHC 18 (Fam)The nature of the case determined the court in which a case concerning the welfare of children or incompetent adults should be litigated: the review of a decision of a public authority by way of JR in the Admin Court; best interests cases in the Family Division. In best interests proceedings the court cannot compel a public authority to exercise its public law functions in a certain way. 2008‑12‑30 22:08:33 2002 cases, Best interests, Detailed summary, Missing from Bailii, Transcript


Re C (Mental Patient: Habeas Corpus) [2002] EWHC 243 (Admin)The application for the issue of a writ of habeas corpus was premature and without any prospect of success; the proper course was to judicially review the Tribunal decision 2008‑12‑21 15:38:30 2002 cases, Detailed summary, Transcript, Unimportant cases


Edwards v UK 46477/99 [2002] ECHR 303Christopher Edwards was killed by a prison cellmate, Richard Linford; both suffered from schizophrenia. (1) The duty under Article 2 to protect life could extend to taking preventive operational measures to protect an individual against criminal acts of another, where the authorities knew (or ought to have known) of a real and immediate risk to the life of an identified individual. Information was available identifying Linford as posing such a risk. The failure to pass on this information, and the inadequate screening of Linford, amounted to a breach of Article 2. (2) No inquest was held, and the trial did not involve witness evidence. The private inquiry which was held (a) had no power to compel witnesses, and (b) was held in private, with the parents unable to participate to the extent necessary to safeguard their interests: Article 2 was breached in this respect. (3) There was no appropriate domestic means of determining whether the authorities failed to protect the right to life or of obtaining compensation, so Article 13 (effective remedy) was breached. 2008‑11‑27 23:17:24 2002 cases, Brief summary, Inquests, Transcript


R (Stevens) v Plymouth City Council, re C [2002] EWCA Civ 388 — Confidentiality. 2008‑10‑15 01:16:44 2002 cases, No summary, Other NR cases, Transcript


R (Morley) v Nottinghamshire Health Care NHS Trust [2002] EWCA Civ 1667 — Disclosure of documents. 2008‑10‑15 01:02:53 2002 cases, No summary, Other criminal law cases, Transcript


R (Morley) v Nottinghamshire Health Care NHS Trust [2002] EWCA Civ 1728In relation to the Secretary of State's power to remit a transferred prisoner back to prison under s50, the patient has no right to make representations, although the circumstances may require the Secretary of State to make further enquiries. 2008‑10‑15 01:01:57 2002 cases, Brief summary, Other criminal law cases, Transcript


R (SSHD) v MHRT, re Grey [2002] EWCA Civ 1053 — Permission to appeal refused (unexplained delay) 2008‑09‑13 06:35:01 2002 cases, No summary, Permission hearings, Transcript


R (RA) v SSHD [2002] EWHC 1618 (Admin) — Power to grant/refuse permission for leave after deferred conditional discharge. 2008‑09‑12 16:47:17 2002 cases, Ministry of Justice, No summary, Transcript


R (S) v MHRT [2002] EWHC 2522 (Admin) — Medical member's role. 2008‑09‑12 16:36:24 2002 cases, Bias, No summary, Transcript


R (N) v Dr M [2002] EWCA Civ 1789 — Challenge to compulsory treatment. 2008‑02‑22 15:29:10 2002 cases, Challenges to compulsory treatment, Detailed summary, Transcript


R (SSG) v Liverpool City Council [2002] EWHC 4000 (Admin)Gay partner can qualify as nearest relative under six-month residence provision in s26(6). 2007‑02‑18 15:36:55 2002 cases, Brief summary, Other NR cases, Transcript


R (IH) v SSHD [2002] EWCA Civ 646A deferred conditional discharge is a provisional decision; the MHRT can reconvene to reconsider the case. 2007‑02‑07 21:00:19 2002 cases, Brief summary, Deferred conditional discharge, Transcript


R (A) v Partnerships in Care Ltd [2002] EWHC 529 (Admin)The decision of the private psychiatric hospital to change the focus of a ward was a decision "in relation to the exercise of a public function" and so susceptible to JR; the managers were a public authority for HRA purposes. Permission granted. 2007‑02‑07 20:49:01 2002 cases, Brief summary, Miscellaneous, Permission hearings, Transcript


R (P) v MHRT East Midlands and North East Region [2002] EWCA Civ 260Permission to appeal granted on the basis that onus of proof had arguably been placed on the patient; permission to argue that the definition of psychopathic disorder requires the current commission by the patient of either abnormally aggressive conduct or seriously irresponsible conduct. 2007‑02‑07 20:47:56 2002 cases, Brief summary, Miscellaneous, Permission hearings, Transcript


R (P) v MHRT East Midlands and North East Region [2002] EWCA Civ 697Psychopathic disorder can persist for years without causing any abnormally aggressive or seriously irresponsible conduct; it is enough that the disorder of mind has done so in the past and that there is a real risk that, if treatment in hospital is discontinued, it will do so in the future. 2007‑02‑07 20:46:54 2002 cases, Brief summary, Transcript, Treatability test and psychopathic disorder


R (PG) v London Borough of Ealing [2002] EWHC 250 (Admin)The Admin court, following the supercession of RSC Order 53 by CPR Part 54, still retains the power to receive oral evidence and order the cross-examination of witnesses on their witness statements and affidavits. 2007‑02‑07 20:44:16 2002 cases, Brief summary, Other NR cases, Transcript


HM v Switzerland 39187/98 [2002] ECHR 157 — HM was admitted to a nursing home because of neglect. She argued that neglect was not a ground for deprivation of liberty, and that she did not fall into the vagrancy category under Article 5(1). The ECHR held that there had been no deprivation of liberty and so no breach of Article 5(1). HM had capacity to object but was undecided; the clinic were entitled to infer consent from the lack of objection. [Summary required; detailed external summary available.] 2007‑02‑07 20:35:52 2002 cases, Detailed summary, ECHR, ECHR deprivation of liberty cases, Transcript


R (C) v SSHD [2002] EWCA Civ 647HO could not exercise discretion to refer case under s71 after MHRT without good reason; evidence lacking at MHRT hearing was not good reason on the facts; following IH (CA) MHRT remains fully seised of case after a D/C/D; decision to refer quashed. (rough summary) 2007‑02‑06 18:38:35 2002 cases, Brief summary, Ministry of Justice, Transcript


R (Warren) v MHRT London North and East Region [2002] EWHC Admin 811In the circumstances, the brief reasons were sufficient, and the error of law (that the patient was under s47/49 rather than notional s37) did not affect the outcome 2007‑02‑06 18:25:26 2002 cases, Brief summary, Reasons, Transcript


R (Ashworth) v MHRT; R (H) v Ashworth [2002] EWCA Civ 923Appeal on MHRT decision dismissed; appeal on re-sectioning allowed. In a case where the availability of suitable after-care services is a pre-requisite for the discharge criteria to be met, but the Tribunal is in any doubt as to its availability, the Tribunal should adjourn rather than defer discharge to a future date. 2007‑02‑06 18:23:22 2002 cases, Brief summary, Re-sectioning after hearing, Transcript


R (T) v MHRT [2002] EWHC Admin 247Discretion to give MHRT decision/reasons to victim should have been considered. 2007‑02‑06 18:19:21 2002 cases, Brief summary, Publicity, Transcript


Benjamin and Wilson v UK 28212/95 [2002] ECHR 636Technical lifer status violated Article 5(4).

See "Technical lifer" page for background.

2006‑08‑15 22:14:11 2002 cases, Brief summary, ECHR, Ministry of Justice, Transcript


R (B) v MHRT [2002] EWHC 1553 (Admin) — Lack of speedy Tribunal hearing breached Article 5(4). 2006‑04‑16 20:50:36 2002 cases, No summary, Transcript, Tribunal delay


R (KB) v MHRT [2002] EWHC Admin 639Lack of speedy Tribunal hearings breached Article 5(4). 2006‑04‑16 11:46:11 2002 cases, Detailed summary, Transcript, Tribunal delay


R (Wooder) v Dr Feggetter [2002] EWCA Civ 554SOAD should give reasons. 2006‑04‑16 11:41:35 2002 cases, Challenges to compulsory treatment, Detailed summary, Transcript


Article titles

The following 61 pages are in this category.

R